2015-02-26

[Pann] Winner receives praise for their MR removed live singing


Source: Pann | 2015.02.26

1. [+263, -6]  They're good! Wow, they're really good!  I've always known Kang Seungyoon was a great singer but Nam Taehyun caught my eye in this video.  The notes get higher but he doesn't resist and just keeps going comfortably. 

2. [+255, -8]  It's to the point that it's surprising that this video has its MR removed.  Usually most MR removed videos get boring but their harmony makes it work.  These kids deserve to be called a talented group unlike others who aren't deserving of the title.  It's only been 6 months since their debut... I'm anticipating how much more they'll grow and improve as the years go by.

3. [+230, -7]  Winner's awesome ㄷㄷ Their live singing is the top of the top

4. [+107, 0]  Who said Kim Jinwoo couldn't sing?  I'm not even a fan but he's really good! 

5. [+102, 0]  It's the first time I'm analyzing Winner's singing really closely and all of them sing very well!  Their harmony is amazing even though they're still rookies.  They're definitely a talented group.

6. [+96, 0]  Removing the MR seems more of an advantage for these kids than a disadvantage... I never knew they were this good!

7. [+94, 0]  Kim Jinwoo and Lee Seunghoon were criticized by anti-fans before but both of them are actually good singers though?! 

8. [+91, 0]  They sing very well.  I honestly think this is one of the top 5 MR removed videos I've ever seen among idols.

9. [+83, 0]  Don't you dare say that Kim Jinwoo can't sing.  '끝이 났네요/It's Over' is the hardest line to sing from Winner's Empty if you ever try to sing it at the karaoke bar.

10. [+81, 0]  I was honestly doubting how great their MR removed singing would be when I clicked this post... after listening to it, I'm amazed.  Having the MR removed is so much better, seriously. They should just sing without the music.

11. [+81, 0]  I always get goosebumps when I watch this video.  When all five of them sing together, one doesn't have to purposely make his tone higher or lower.  They all just have to sing with their natural voice.  From Mino's low tone to Seunghoon's high tone..  All of their voices match so well that when they sing together it just creates the perfect harmony... I'm really proud of them and I honestly think this group has the best combination.




141 comments :

Arguable said...

Most yg artist Mr removed Is amazing

LoveTabi said...

YES WINNER GET THAT PRAISE!!!! but for real since win they demonstrated their vocal skills so for the fans it's just common knowledge. It always made me mad when people criticized Jinwoo because he was "weak" (wtf??? He's the strongest, never giving up no matter how hard it was) like people love to drag him down because he showed vulnerability but to me that makes me love him more because that makes him human with FEELINGS. Jinwoo had always been a strable singer he only needs more confidence which he is starting to get!!!! He reminds me of Seungri. No matter how good they are and how much they try some people are just gonna blindly hate

gzbitch said...

"These kids deserve to be called a talented group..."

YES. THAT'S RIGHT. AND NO ONE, AND I MEAN NO ONE COULD MAKE ME THINK OTHERWISE.

4. [+107, 0] Who said Kim Jinwoo couldn't sing? I'm not even a fan but he's really good!
7. [+94, 0] Kim Jinwoo and Lee Seunghoon were criticized by anti-fans before but both of them are actually good singers though?!
9. [+83, 0] Don't you dare say that Kim Jinwoo can't sing. '끝이 났네요/It's Over' is the hardest line to sing from Winner's Empty if you ever try to sing it at the karaoke bar.

Jinwoo isn't the best singer. But let's face it, he can sing. And he definitely can improve lot more. Heck, even Mino and Seunghoon could sing. Have you seen those two harmonized? You should.

Chubby chubby said...

The first time I've watched this I was speechless. They're too excellent

bumbum said...

im so proud to the point where i have tears in my eyes *cries*

namxx__ said...

Im so proud of you boys!! they are deserve to be called a Talented group.. i got goosebumps bcs of beautiful harmony.. Hoon and Mino can singing too❤

meh said...

5 singers and 4 rappers. Kim Jinwoo is on his way to be rapper too lol

abunnsky said...

I rewatch this video almost everyday and I prefer the mr removed version than the original. The harmony at the end tho.. they all sing together~
get that love babies ^^

http://38.media.tumblr.com/f928d9d9fc4ed9c65841298f2237f217/tumblr_njp7yuKOst1u73bhao2_r1_250.gif

lolbye said...

Lol, please.


Taehyun is a very inconsistent, nasally singer. Sketchbook is known to 'correct' their live performances for TV.


KSY & Mino are the saving grace of WINNER, essentially the backbone that carries WINNER. Not a bad thing. Jinwoo remains an untalented mess and LSH can continue pretending to be a rapper.

hikari17 said...

Did anyone get chills at the last part where Taehyun sang? .-. His voice is like velvet.

bumbum said...

try harder next time. bye~

abunnsky said...

you need this?

innercircle said...

LOL, PLEASE... you can be a JUDGES someday! LOL.... thanks for your pathetic comment tht truly rubbish..

macy_12 said...

WINNER is seriously amazing w/their lives. It's even scarier when people realize that they're barely 6 months old.... Their live is at the top.
That is also one of the best MR's I've heard. WINNER babies are amazing!!!


Also, iKON's likely to join this, their live is insanely good.
YG really struck gold another round w/these 2.

okaybyee said...

*Cries with you.*

macy_12 said...

sure.... i smell butthurt because someone's faves is incapable....

Mjnia said...

Hey hun... first learn about Namtaehyun and other members before making an ignorant comment... thanks for paying attention to WINNER tho... ;)

okaybyee said...

Wow did u just made ur account for this? Lmao ok then be happy always ms. perfect

princekyung said...

Lol @ how you made this account just to post this comment?

cigaretteplease said...

The best in their generation.

Bobby-KimJiWon said...

I love Nam Taehyun's singing in Missing You so much. His voice stands out the most in the cover

abunnsky said...

lmao he's still practicing for his rap
@ 1:52 sorry I can't find the english sub >.<

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-jDrClaylwA

Riyadh Prawiryo Att said...

All YG artist is soooo good in MR removed live singing.

hannaxxy said...

What's even more sad is this person prob upvoted their own comment lol...

cigaretteplease said...

Butthurt hahaha

YanaGrace said...

All of YG groups MR are amazing!

gellz said...

lol yet you're so bothered that you made an account just to post this comment? Listen to that MR removed again and let it cure you of your chronic case of butthurt.

cigaretteplease said...

What makes this even more awesome is that they improved so much from the time they performed it during WINNERTV. They know their strengths and weaknesses and they aim to perfect their skills. Things could only get better and brighter for Winner.

fatin hashim said...

yuckkkk! buthurt ??? ahhahahhahahha.. you can sing better than jinwoo and namtea or can be rapper to replace hoon?.. LOL try again haters! you need this btw.. go away shuhhhhh !

엿먹어 said...

9. [+83, 0] Don't you dare say that Kim Jinwoo can't sing. '끝이 났네요/It's Over' is the hardest line to sing from Winner's Empty if you ever try to sing it at the karaoke bar.



YES. I have tried and I can't even sound half as good as Jinwoo.


ALSO MOST YG SONGS are so hard to pull of at the karaoke bar!!!!! They make it look so easy but it's so not

WINNERCIRCLE said...

Well if you don't think they're talented (which they all definitely are), then you can just shut the f*** up.

Don't use your words to criticize, use them to support your favorite singers and rappers that you think are talented.

And don't you f****** dare say "You guys are such wusses for being offended." You don't need to go around hurting a fandom's feelings. What if we go and insult your idol? You're DEFINITELY going to get defensive. Hands down. Denying it just means you would totally be offended.

WINNER members didn't do shit to make you look down upon them. You don't deserve to look down on them, anyways.

You and I can try to critique each others idols all we want, but we can't even do whatever our idols can do. Sing? Both you and I probably horrible pitch and are probably off tune. Rap? Ha, we'd suck.

And you've never been to a WINNER concert. They sing so damn well. Taehyun's dropped his nasally voice a long time ago. Jinwoo's singing is phenomenal compared to his WIN days. Seunghoon, I don't even need to say anything because his improvement is so great compared to his days on KPOP star. Have you seen him compose his first rap? That was hilarious, but he tried. Now his raps as a member of WINNER is touching and soothing. Every singer has their own flaws, but the only thing they can do is improve, and that is what the members of WINNER are doing.

So you can just your sorry, criticizing ass away from an article revolving WINNER and kiss up to the idols you adore.

Ok, bye.

xin said...

they sing well when their songs are ballads but when the song is upbeat Taehyun and jinwoo are still weak, out of tune and off of air... only their leader can actually sing decent, and the rappers are good for me,

but I believe they're gonna be better with the years :)

mydeand said...

are u deaf

disqus_iZK3nWDY6v said...

Umm, Seungri is eons more talented than Jinwoo, let's not even go there. I find the Chanwoo/Jinwoo comparisons to Seungri so ridiculous, none of them have the hunger and drive Seungri does to achieve things.

duende said...

my sons

bumblebee said...

lolbye~~

Daeyoon said...

aww,,,,

sdgsd said...

Flawless.

darey99 said...

https://38.media.tumblr.com/cde4326e350d2163ef55246a7d92cf95/tumblr_n4w6i1ifgA1sodo64o1_250.gif

Camiliuuu said...

proud to my boys !!! the most talent group in the kpop with big bang !!!! thank you for beginig my winner babies !!!

sdgsd said...

I didn't realize Seungri still had fans to defend him. He's not "eons more" talented, he's an average singer and dancer, just as Jinwoo is. Jinwoo imo is even better but that's personal preference.

bitbig2 said...

Yep..they have many years to learn to be better...
Even taeyang or seungri can be unstable when they sing upbeat songs...but because they have more experience...they know how to handle it..adlibs :)

cigaretteplease said...

I dont agree with anyone of them being more talented than the other but you're being butthurt and too literal in op's comment. Jinwoo just reminds her of Seungri and nothing more. So stop.

Kpopismylife2010 said...

Let's not make this a NetizenBuzz 2.0 please...We are all YG Stans so let's get along. If you don't like a YG group then don't check on their articles stop wasting your time just to leave annoying comments. Leave and never come back please. BYE

mydeand said...

Please let's not fight. We can't compare rookies with someone such as Seungri. They'll still improve, of course.

bumblebee said...

[+81, 0] I always get goosebumps when I
watch this video. When all five of them sing together, one doesn't have
to purposely make his tone higher or lower. They all just have to sing
with their natural voice. From Mino's low tone to Seunghoon's high
tone.. All of their voices match so well that when they sing together
it just creates the perfect harmony... I'm really proud of them and I
honestly think this group has the best combination.

mfpn said...

People who are still criticized and bring down Taehyun's singing is really living in the past. I bet they never watch their live performances. He is the best at harmonizing and his live is better. Their wwic performances will prove it.

7. [+94, 0] Kim Jinwoo and Lee Seunghoon were criticized by anti-fans before but both of them are actually good singers though?!

Jinwoo is indeed improved. All he needs is confidence. He is not seungyoon, but he def can sing. And I don't understand why people said seunghoon is talentless like.. what? If you follow them, seunghoon is not talentless. He is the one who makes their live performances interesting and his stage presence is the best. Yg don't promote him as rapper but dancer. So he is not talentless.

Both of them are not useless.
Lol at people who are trying to make winner as talentless group. You can tell how popular they are.

xin said...

I agree!! this is only the beginning I know that they can improve just like their sumbaes, I mean the voice is there, only a bit more of practice and they gonna slay :)

xin said...

uhmm? is just my point of view~ problem?

mfpn said...

YOU are the one who start the comparing game. The op just said that jinwoo remind him of seungri because no matter how much they improved people will always try to bring them down. Just like how you did here.

Reem Bd said...

winner i hate you boys don`t be so perfect i`m sorry But I loved them so much when I see articles like this I really cry i mean it i feel so happy i mean this is my baby's .
winner you are a great group you have wonderful voices and no one can say the opposite love you my boys

mfpn said...

Ikr. That's really a dedication right there. I even can smell butthurt through my screen here. Lol

MagIC said...

why is he soooooooooooooooo cute

commedesfuckdown said...

The person above was reminded of Seungri because Jinwoo is being underappreciated for his talent, I guess. KJW certainly can sing, he has a really nice voice. But of course, Seungri is a huge sunbae to him with two self written relatively successful solo albums under his belt.

commedesfuckdown said...

Lol wtf, pf course Seungri has fans. VIP is a huge fandom.

gurl said...

'I didn't realize Seungri still had fans to defend him.'

umm

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B-0fQ9fVIAETvgN.jpg

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B-0fRlSVEAAGzgY.jpg

commedesfuckdown said...

ALL.

nami said...

why are you even comparing them? she clearly stated there that jinwoo reminds him of seungri and that's it. she didn't say that jinwoo is better than seungri or vice versa. lmao stop exaggerating and twisiting someone's words.

hongsiiii said...

ot but


OMG IS THAT HONGSEOK


MY BABY ;_______________;


LMAO IS THIS RECENT

commedesfuckdown said...

They are handsome, talented, funny. Comeback with a good album!

maltesers said...

well said k-netz.. i like to slap this video to all the haters of jinwoo and seunghoon.. my 5 pabos is talented individually.. if u stll can't see the talent until now.. go into hiatus and reflect..hahaha..


hail the king!!!our talented boy's!!lol

commedesfuckdown said...

Is he still in YG? I have heard the other one left...

mfpn said...

My comment has nothing to do with "sunbae hoobae" thing.
I was just responding to that user that she/he is the one who start to compare seungri and jinwoo when the op just stated that jinwoo is remind her to seungri. That's all. Did she said jinwoo is better than seungri? No.
Some user here really like to twisting words.

commedesfuckdown said...

I didnt mean to reply to you, I was replying to disqus_i7...

puppy said...

Yes.

Jinhyeong left, he's on IG
https://instagram.com/artb_jay/

Arguable said...

Try gotta be you bom part the falsetto I swear I could not pull it off

commedesfuckdown said...

Thank god. He was my fav 💕

withwink_ said...

Winner get the praises and users here refuse to acknowledged it. Well that's speak a lot lol. They must be popular that people are so butthurt.

Winner, keep going up! :D

MagIC said...

Please dont talk like that of Seungri ,Winner respect their Seniors, and IC knows that Winner will improve more :)

withwink_ said...

Now gurl, don't go there. I am seungri's fan so yes he still has fans.

lol said...

I'm surprised Jinwoo didn't get the rapping role, most idols who have no skills are the rappers, like SHINee's Minho.

withwink_ said...

All of them is guest? Omg that's really embarrassing. But I can see the dedication. A+ for that.

commedesfuckdown said...

Obviously trolling. Ignore.

lol @ incles said...

Child, if Seungri didn't pick up Jinwoo from the fishing pond in Imjado Island and drop him off to YG, Jinwoo would be singing off key tunes while farming cabbage to make his village's kimchi right now.


Let's not.

cutedevil0912 said...

bc Jinwoo's main role is Winner's visual

abunnsky said...

child your dedication to winner tho.. lmao how many acc do you have?

MagIC said...

http://24.media.tumblr.com/c8bfcc45a12d8dcab321aa623bb12c57/tumblr_mxeuqc4m5J1skwvu2o1_r2_250.gif

MagIC said...

Full of Swag
https://31.media.tumblr.com/465593989e688c0b1a833b5cb0898eec/tumblr_nbhk2i8VxQ1r6vdleo1_500.gif

Mjnia said...

lol... its funny how you know so much about Jinwoo and "his hunger and drive to achieve things". LoveTabi stated how Jinwoo is similar to Seungri when Seungri started out. If you watched the BB documentary, you'll understand how he was the shown as the weakest and even cut from the group. He then proved to YG that he belonged in the group and was chosen again.

Like Tabi said, Seungri's drive and Jinwoo's are similar in that ppl. saw the weaker side of them and they kept on going and going to become singers in their own rights.

mfpn said...

Lol @ YOU btw. xD

nami said...

you're basically butthurt.

omg said...

He's so ugly, winner's visuals would have been alright w/o him.

WINNERCIRCLE said...

If you think he's so useless, why don't you go in and replace him? Are you that great to say he's useless?
He's improving everyday, he's doing everything he can and putting in all his effort to be acknowledged, but people like you put down that effort as if he only spends a few seconds practicing.

What if you studied hard for a test only to have people call you stupid? No matter how hard you studied, or how many great exam scores you got, people just called you stupid because maybe you weren't bright in the past.

Jinwoo wasn't that great during his WIN days, but he has improved tremendously, but because you aren't an INCLE, or a fan who has been with WINNER since the starting of their journey, you wouldn't know.

WINNERCIRCLE said...

For those of you who are misinterpreting LoveTabi's messaghe and using this misunderstanding to downgrade Jinwoo's talent:

If you think he's so useless, why don't you go in and replace him? Are you that great to say he's useless?
He's improving everyday, he's doing everything he can and putting in all his effort to be acknowledged, but people like you put down that effort as if he only spends a few seconds practicing.

What if you studied hard for a test only to have people call you stupid? No matter how hard you studied, or how many great exam scores you got, people just called you stupid because maybe you weren't bright in the past.

Jinwoo wasn't phenomenal during his WIN days, but he has improved tremendously, but because you aren't an INCLE, or a fan who has been with WINNER since the starting of their journey, you wouldn't know.

Nodila said...

Jinwoo can sing well ,just don't hv a nice and unique voice like other two members.He is not useless,he is visual of the group and he can sing well more than most of other groups visual.

WINNERCIRCLE said...

Seriously, this bitchy, untalented, pitiful Outercircle is as dedicated to hatin' as much as INCLES are dedicated to WINNER.

withwink_ said...

Aww so cute. ♡
Sidenote: don't reply to troll because she/he is just a laughing stock right now lmao. Here I'll give you qtpie seunghoon. :p

Nodila said...

Why are they all that handsome?First I saw Jinwoo,i thought he is visual of the group.Then Nam Taehyun,omg that guy is so pretty. And my eyes move to Lee Seung Hoon,stunning the whole top to bottom, then Song Mino who is so manly good-looking.Then I saw Kang Seung Yoon,I can't ignore his flower boy face and so cute as puppy. Can't choose,I love them all 5 after DBSK.

lyra2015 said...

wonder why the news comes today as this video was uploaded last year?

cheyanne said...

Your just jelous!!go to hell!!

withwink_ said...

That's troll. He/she create multiple of account right now. You can see in this comment section. Lol such a dedicated hater.

MagIC said...

For me is NamDiva :)
My Visual Ranking
1. NamTae
2. KangSongLeeKim
http://24.media.tumblr.com/dc0c243061a70ba54ed0aaa108c8335e/tumblr_muii4jAyK41s8mz29o1_400.gif

cheyanne said...

Just burn yourself to hell!your not needed here!!

withwink_ said...

Let's cool down. That user is obvious troll. Lol

cheyanne said...

I really like jinwoo's voice esp in dont flirt,his tonight part and but song ending part!

WinnerisLove said...

They are perfect!!! I love them soooo much

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BrNzEw-CEAIWCPz.jpg

maltesers said...

well maybe when god shower good looks this 5 pabo is on the first row while in chaos fighting for the first..hahaha.. expect a total chaos!!!!

smh said...

Tablo can try to teach Jinwoo how to rap.

Maybe then, incles will stop hating him :)

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B-NiySFIEAAUDsW.jpg

Nodila said...

OMG, I like this style the most. I secretly wish this to be their next CB concept.

tbvh said...

It's not news,YG press translated a recent pann which is just like fans writing articles about their faves and other fans comment. Sometimes yg press does high upvoted YG panns. Aka this one :)

Nodila said...

For me,my heart is so weak,so it just happens alternative bias system,can't help.

cheyanne said...

You always criticize that jinwoo is the weakest but you know he adds flavor/color to the group!!and there's a reason why he became part of the winner! Many people are more talented than jinwoo,that sings better than jinwoo but why they are still trainees or still nugu?jinwoo is destine to be a star!so just accept it and move on from bitterness!

mfpn said...

Maybe then, you can stop creating new accounts. And stop upvoting your own comment lol this is embarrassing and pathetic.

jo22k . said...

slay WINNER, get that praise! They slay, they are all just talented! <3 cant wait for the comeback

bunbun said...

lee seung hoon isn't really a rapper....he's a dancer....

Anonymous said...

pls say amazing rapperS, aru is improving too :(
mino is good but why say rapper not rappers...

lyra2015 said...

Ooo, so its like random discussion?

tbvh said...

Yeah it's basicslly like a tumblr post I guess - and fans upvote/downvote and comment and the most popular ones "trend" and get attention. They're written about eveything - from fanstuff to lifestyle and problems ....check out Twitter user pannchoa if you want to read more. Some are really interesting.

addedyou said...

oppps bitter alert the more you insulting jinwoo. the more pathetic you are.

princess ariel said...

I absolutely love the mr removed and especially how you can hear seunghoon's voice clearly during the harmony omg I listen to this on my bad days and feel like I've just drowned myself in holy angel voices thanks

InnerCircleLovesWINNER said...

:)

withwink_ said...

Idk know who are you and why are you making this new account just to reply to me...

ramenboy said...

I thought I was the only one who found Jinwoo's part the hardest to sing.

HappyMaknae said...

YGPRESS is so relevant nowadays xD We even have haters now xDDD

titan-kun said...

Seungri is love
Jinwo is love
Winner and Bigbang are Love

Troll, multiple acc, failed

Millie said...

u can go now
no one want u here :|

titan-kun said...

This is the first time i saw ygpress comment section in a mess. Lol at the failed troll invasion. Inner circle lets just ignore them ya

titan-kun said...

Lol damn. Why are you like this? Why you choose to be like this. Leave Seungri alone and while you at it just leave Jinwoo alone too.

#GodDragon pls help this soul

titan-kun said...

Wait...no one is comparing them though.

Ninni said...

one of my fave style of them <33

Kaila said...

Ahhh. One of Kang's eyes is missing some eyeliner LOL.

Pastel said...

One of my top favorite mr removed performances from winner: missing you. I always get so much feels listening 2ne1 versions I thought no other can give me the same feels. But winner did amazing. Their voices blend together very nicely <3 jinwoo's voice is nice and calming too

titan-kun said...

This thread lol attack of rage circle.
aaah I love inner circle.

titan-kun said...

chaelin-aaaah!!!!!!

*i read you comment with her voice in my head

Lumiere said...

imagine pann like the OH forum

Lumiere said...

bye

Kristen said...

He's deleted his comment. Can you tell me wat did he say? 😡

Kristen said...

wow.....did you read her comment clearly? I think you misunderstood and now you are the person who compare three of them 😡

guest said...

Yes babies get those praises!! Even their rappers can sing and harmonize with their vocal line, Yoon can also rap. XD I honestly got goosebumps when i heard Jinwoo sing live And He's really good. . :))

Jenizz | pinkcrown said...

♡♡♡♡♡♡♡ :)

gdgom said...

My babieeeees<3

Samira said...

Jinwoo improved so much compared to win days

MagIC said...

hahaha its okay sometimes i cheat taehyun with Mino hahahha All of them are so handsome :)
PD: welcome to InnerCircle fandom <3

Dhyanne Kwon said...

What's more amazing about Winner? Rapper line can definitely sing and the vocals can rap...hoping that there will be a song/songs in their comeback album that will highlight this...

WINNERCIRCLE said...

"Jinwoo is basically WINNER's Dara.
Except Dara had a large fanbase during her, so that was okay.
Jinwoo is useless, tbh."

**Just clarifying** THESE ARE THE WORDS OF THE TROLL. NOT MINE.

Yeah, his/her comment made me so angry >:(

NunmulBaboBB said...

LOL...I love this picture...Dying @Mino's face. lol

NunmulBaboBB said...

Was that video of the boys switching their song parts ever released?.....I remember checking EVERYWHERE couple of months ago but couldn't find it. Would love to hear it if anyone has a link.

sushicshi said...

Sadly, there's none... i've been searching everywhere too and all i could find is the audio ver in soundcloud... (i forgot where i saw the link tho...i'll share it here when i find it ><)


there's also 1 video cut where Mino belted Yoon's part in Empty (that video tho was not when they switched their parts, it's when Mino helped SY with his part coz it looked like his throat was in bad condition, i'm not so sure)

Coffee said...

i didn't know he was on ig! do you know if hongseok has one too?

Kristen said...

The case is HATER GONNA HATE , and the fact is WE ARE UNABLE TO KILL CREEPY ANTS.

Yellow said...

YGPress is starting to have trolls, too? Lol.

Post a Comment