2014-08-11

WINNER Finally Debuts! Achieves An All-Kill, #1 on the Charts!

Source: OSEN, Xsportsnews, OSEN (2), TV Report


-

1. [+3694, -567]  All the tracks are good.  As expected, YG makes great songs.  They go out with a bang.

2. [+3057, -477]  Their songs are really good.  I hope they do well.

3. [+2724, -443]  All of the songs in this album are amazing ㅠㅠ I love Color Ring so much ㅠㅠ

4. [+2390, -440]  The title songs and the other tracks... every one of them is just so good! ♡♡

5. [+2358, -413]  I just love all of the songs ㅠㅠ  They deserve the all-kill on the charts. 

6. [+589, -76]  YG annoyingly doesn't stick to his release dates but the songs they release are always so good.  I always end up forgiving him because of the songs... it's like a love and hate relationship.

7. [+552, -89]  This is the first time I've seen a rookie rank like that for a debut album...  I can see them growing to be as much as Big Bang or 2NE1 or maybe even more than that.  YG's daebak.

8. [+529, -84]  You can't say that this is because they're from YG because all of the songs are actually really good.  No matter how great the company is, listeners these days are something else.  If the song isn't good, it's impossible for all of them to top the charts in a line. 

9. [+483, -64]  I thought they would definitely go with a dance song but they went with a lyrical, dream-like style.  Winner must have worried a lot about trying to find a unique colour but I'm so glad that the results turned out great.  Congratulations!  I hope Winner always tries to grow and learn.  I'm a bit sad that I won't be able to see Taehyun's dope dancing though.

10. [+412, -71]  Winner's just daebak.  Color Ring is daebak.  YG... daebak.
-


1. [+2142, -220]  I love Empty so much!!  The MV doesn't seem like it's from a rookie either.  It's so classy ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ

2. [+1942, -188]  The songs are great ㅋ I like how they carry a different feeling than Big Bang

3. [+1706, -161]  Heol... it's just.... daebak.

4. [+1592, -149]  ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ Daebak!  Seriously!  It was worth the wait.

5. [+1543, -141]  Ah... daebak....  it's an album that was worth the long wait. 

6. [+1307, -120]  They're really not the second Big Bang.  They're artists called Winner with their own strong colour.  All of the songs are distinct and amazing.

7. [+1113. -113]  Wow, it's really bursting with emotion...  They didn't try to make a catchy song but just stuck with their true colours and released the music they wanted to show.

8. [+1009, -116]  The song EMPTY is honestly so good!

9. [+996, -121]  It's not a typical boy group idol song.  Winner really tried to differentiate themselves.  I can see the amount of effort and work Winner and YG put into this. 

10. [+862, -98]  It's the best... seriously... it's just daebak..
-


1. [+571, -50]  I can't believe Winner is debuting~~~~ ♡ Color Ring, Empty♡

2. [+521, -41]  Winner is truly... the winner.

3. [+490, -43]  Winner's songs are all so good!  The title songs and the other tracks are all great.  

4. [+419, -23]  Empty is really good!

5. [+378, -32]  I hope they become big after all the work and effort they've put all this time!  Winner, fighting!

-

1. [+685, -66]  I love their songs...

2. [+624, -64]  Song Mino = GD + Taeyang Feel

3. [+524, -57]  I'm loving their songs... it's on repeat.

4. [+453, -55]  The songs are great... I wasn't sure at first but once you listen to it more and more, you start to fall for it.  It's so good!

5. [+467, -81]  Winner, Yang Hyun Suk, all the composers, everyone that helped, B.I, Bobby, I thank you all so much ㅜㅜ I'll become a proud Inner Circle.  The songs are all amazing!!!!!!!!!  Kang-Nam-Kim-Song-Lee, let's rock the world!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥


55 comments :

QQ said...

"[+589, -76] YG annoyingly doesn't stick to his release dates but the songs they release are always so good. I always end up forgiving him because of the songs... it's like a love and hate relationship." ain't this every yg stan's story LOL

LoveTabi said...

"They're really not the second Big Bang. They're artists called Winner with their own strong colour. All of the songs are distinct and amazing."

THIS SO MUCH OMG IM SO PROUD OF THEM THEY GOT A REAL TIME ALL KILL LIKE YES MY BABIES DESERVE IT SO MUCH I WAS EXPECTING SOME DANCE TRACK BUT THEY CAME OUT WITH UTTERLY PERFECTION
it honestly doesn't feel like a debut album made by rookies, it gives of the impression of an album made by veterans so so so proud of them and I know they will be BIG i have huge hopes for them ((im sure YG does too bc he realized that anything that has winner on in is getting sell out so now he's even selling candles with winner's name on it lmao))
they're acting is A+++++
they're honestly all so well rounded YG is lucky to have found them

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

Taehyun just skyrocketed to the top 5 of my kpop bias.

anon said...

Kang-Nam-Kim-Song-Lee, let's rock the world!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥

Kpopismylife2010 said...

Where are all the hater that were saying that they were not gonna support empty cause it was made by Double b...Where did they go? I'm looking for you like

gzbitch said...

I feel like crying for Winner. The praise they're getting is well deserved. I am just so proud of them. Color Ring made me tear up.

dboy said...

Empty is totally my style ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ Don't Flirt is also good and I'm Him is SO YG AND I LOVE IT. Their concept just screams CLASSY~

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

Seriously, have you guys twerk after listen to Mino's solo?
I think I found a shower jam.

ninikai said...

Damn that panty-dropping voice is sexy or what?!

gzbitch said...

IS ANYONE ELSE DYING AT TAEHYUN AND JINWOO'S FALSETTO IN EMPTY? HOON'S RAP IN COLOR RING? MINO'S PUSSY POPPIN' SOLO? AND SEUNGYOON'S VOICE IN EACH TRACK? I'M SURE I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE. COME ON NOW.

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

That's why I said there is a reason why YG will choose that song. Color Ring is nice but lacks that 'WoW' factor and a lot of commenters from other sites call it boring. Empty is also considered boring to those who dont like slow song but at least it is a hip hop mix and with a bit r&b feel.
I aint being biased because my top fav song in this album is another song Winner composed.

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

Mino is sexy and he knows it.

dboy said...

2014 YG All-Kill Relay NO BIGGIE
Seriously I love YG... All my fav artists are in YG now :')

the accidental pro said...

can't think of any other better compliment for them.... THEY DESRVE EVERYTHING....

rhiaresa said...

dat little saxophone break #yessss...it gives me so much life

EE said...

Song was good.
But definitely not the BEST in the album.
Songs like Different or Tonight could've been used as a 2nd title track following Coloring.


Coloring and Empty have a similar feel and even the MVs look similar.
I actually find it strange that YG decided to go with 2 slow songs as title tracks.
and obviously Empty was gonna do good its the 1st title song placed as the 1st track in the album sung by Winner (ICs support) and composed by BIBobby (TB fans support) and the MV was released 1st.
OF course this song was going to hit big... if it didn't it would have been really strange....

EE said...

but now you're comparing Winner "rookie" group who just debuted to GD (well established artist).
The fault in your comparison is that GENERAL PUBLIC will only listen to Winner's title track (Empty & Coloring). They won't bother with the rest of the album cause the way they think is : "If YG choose these 2 as title tracks it means they are the ABSOLUTE best EVER".
Whereas with GD, people already know about him and will take time to actually listen to the WHOLE album not only the title tracks.

macy_12 said...

wooohoooo, here i was a bit nervous by these commentors, surprised from these comments no Bom comment came up. i honestly don't think her scandal will lessen any excitement from their debut & it didn't.


BUTTTT all the long wait, it was worth it. the tittles are beautiful & the album is beautiful! tbh i didnt get the rookie vibe from them, it felt more like veterans making a comeback. right off the spot they established their sounds is what I'm guessing for their veteran sound. but omg omg omgg!! it finally happened!!!

Hanbin_BonBon said...

The guitar riff on "Empty" combined with sad lyrics and magical voices and rap of the members. IT DESERVES AN ALL KILL. Woohoo!! "Im Him" is too much I cant handle my ass and hip! HAH!

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

I dont think it's because the general public dont care about the whole album. They have more 3 songs charting on Melon top10. It's not that easy to have 3 songs charting in melon and consider that they are just rookies(not even popular groups like JYJ/Girl's day/Sistar with their recent comeback have multiple tracks charted in top 10. That just proved that the public is buying more than one song.
In the other reply, didnt you talk about Color Ring is charting high as well? Isnt it contradict to what you're saying(the public only care about first title song statement)?

Carmen Carrera said...

Thank god I wasn't the only one worried about Bom comments (or drug comments in general about YG). It just shows that most people have decided that it's not worth mentioning again and again (not saying they've moved on or anything but you get the idea)

EE said...

as of right now, they only have 3 songs in top 10 of Melon (pic below). a great achievement for Winner !! but shows that people are mostly interested in the Title tracks (which are at #1 and #2) other songs not charting as high.


Coloring is charting well cause its the SECOND TITLE track. it isn't a random song in the album... so no it doesn't contradict my argument. it actually proves it that general public will only listen to title tracks.

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

I dont get it. Both are title tracks and I just think that Empty is doing better simply because it appeals more to the public but the public is still buying both songs.
I hope our discussion doesnt turn to another A vs B arguments because I have no ill intention to kill the party.

EE said...

a little discussion and having different opinions =/= being a hater.


i respect your opinion i just don't agree with it. i see things differently not at face value. there are various REASONS as to why Empty is doing good (not gonna repeat myself here lol).

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

yea I know having different opinion=/= being a hater but I just scare that the comment section will turn into another arguments.Kpop fans in general are sensitive you know lol

EE said...

they should learn to grow and just ignore comments that bother them if they're not able to have a civilized convo.

Bald Mr.Worldwide said...

Maybe a collaboration stage on Gayo Daejun or YG Fam concert?
CL must like it since Mino seems to be her type xD

dboy said...

i think all of us have now developed a phobia of clicking into articles because we're scared we'll see bom's comments ...sigh

1Name said...

6. [+1307, -120]  They're really not the second Big Bang.  They're artists called Winner with their own strong colour.  All of the songs are distinct and amazing.


This!!!!

Usui Takumi said...

the feels -screams-

GG said...

Empty, Tonight, Confession and my boy Mino's I'm Him are my jam

GG said...

I have much respect for Hoon. I knew him since Kpop Star and this boy improved so much. They trained him well and boy must put in so much effort !!! He doesnt seem to be lacking compared to his talented bandmates.

GG said...

Gotta give it to YG that they also teach their rapper to sing. Daebak !!! i mean you dont need a rap in every song.

Kungd said...

Last comment make me sob :)) so truee. Thanks everyone who brings us this album

Ri said...

MINO'S INTRO RAP BYE LIFE LET ME JUMP TO THE SEA OF FEELS

SK said...

The positivity makes me happy!!! <3<3<3

bitbig2 said...

please make it happen...
i can imagine how it will be.. please... >.<

bitbig2 said...

i wanna cry for Different...i can feel Seungyoon touch there.. T.T

Kayla said...

I really like Empty , I'm him and different . That being said , I still think that for a group who was supposed to sound different and not-your-usual-YGgroup-ish , It is pretty underwhelming . If a group from a nugu label would have debuted with this album , they wouldnt have gone really far . And I'm not hating , please dont misunderstand me , But I'm quite disappointed in YG for not trying harder with winner and choosing an album full of basic public friendly songs that we've been hearing for decades in the West


Congratulations for your debut and your first #1 on Melon Winner , and congratulations to B.I and Bobby too ( I just hope that now , some people are regretting some of the things they said about them before the song was out )

mek0 said...

Yes! Like his dance and charisma is what got him that far in Kpop Star, because his rapping and singing was just ok (although I still love his babylion rap). But now hearing him in this album, I can't help but be so proud of his improvement. Now I definitely can't wait to see their choreography. Hopefully he was allowed to take the reins on that one.

Saerhin said...

So the boys chose to not dance :') if that's the case then arasso! All I am is happy for my babies to be debuting :')

Now I'll be supporting them and wait for Team B ♡

Lumiere said...

when i saw the track list i thought that coloring ring will be mellow while empty will have a bit more umf.so i was a bit disappointed when i saw that both are mellow.i wished they replaced empty with something more upbeat

Blank said...

I mean Mino also contributed to the song and I feel like it has Winner style rather than TB style... I can't imagine TB singing this song cause i feel like they are more better in up-beat songs rather than slow songs(just me) but let's just enjoy the album rather than hating on double b for contributing on the winner album(not saying you said this but other comments i've seen.)

Blank said...

OMFG. MINO'S SOLO DESERVES AN M/V AS WELL. IT'S LIKE MTBD TO ME.

Amanda Rachel said...

You know my feeling about EMPTY

GG said...

His dance routine in WiN finally was daebak. one of the best dance in kpop imo.

kaede said...

[+521, -41] Winner is truly... the winner.

Definitely.

kaede said...

Yey! I get to see you again! I can see your comment here.

kaede said...

Me too! It's so refreshing reading positive notes from knetz.

Saerhin said...

Omg Me too! I'm so happy to finally see you tbh Hahah I was panicking I thought they banned some users xD

Saerhin said...

There is an MV for Mino's solo :) just don't fckn kno when it'll be released... probably 2013938829922929292

lilinai said...

i think seunghoon and jinwoo show their great improvement. i can't stop saying that i'm really proud to be their fan!

gzbitch said...

Right. Hoon's rapping is way so much better now. And Jinwoo... My, my Jinwoo. *-*

JustMyOpinion said...

I'm definitely with EE. I think Empty is doing well than Color Ring because the MV was released first. Some people think Color Ring is boring might be because they already listened to Empty and expected an up beat song for the next MV. Since it's composed by DoubleB, of course TB's fans rooting for the song too (ICs+TB's fans rooting for Empty) meanwhile mostly ICs rooting for Color Ring (TB's fans might be rooting for Color Ring too but not as much as for Empty). As for your comparison, Black doesn't have a MV meanwhile Who You has MV so obviously it gonna attracts more people to listen to it hence resulting to more people buying it. If I'm not a GD fan, I totally won't even know about Black and only know about Who You because it has MV. Is it only me or it seems like you favor TB more than Winner? Just asking because I read most of your comments about Winner and TB and it seems like you like TB more.

Barrakwouda said...

VOTE FOR WINNER http://mwave.interest.me/star/poll/result.m?poll_seq=319 WE ARE LOOSING AGAINST BTS !:!:!

Post a Comment